Favorites Pizza & Wings Amherst – Best Thin-Crust Pizza, Wings & More in Buffalo, NY

So glad they opened this location after being addicted to the one in Lewiston. Just as good as original. So many good kinds, it's hard to pick a "favorite"! After getting my usual of hamburger(big mac) and honey garlic chicken for a while, i stopped in today to find they had a steak bacon and jalapeño popper slice....so good

Favorites is our new go-to pizzeria! Their slice special can't be beat! It includes 2 slices and a can of soda for $5 (including tax). They have a huge selection of slices to choose from, from open to close. My favorite varieties are the old fashioned and honey chicken. Their soda cooler is always well-stocked also. We've ordered subs a few times too. My boyfriend said their chicken finger sub is better than Jim's! My son loves the kid's chicken finger meal which includes fingers, fries and a 2-pack of chocolate chip cookies. The fried dough is also good with a sprinkling of powdered sugar.The interior is immaculate, which is a huge plus. Every member of the staff that I've dealt with has been incredibly friendly. Give them a try!

The staff was super nice and helpful when I was deciding what to order. They got me to try the stinger burger. It was soooo good! I've had their pizza before and it was pretty good too! Can't wait to come back!

A Pleasant Surprise in a World of Overpriced Pizza As someone who takes their pizza and wings seriously, I’ve become increasingly frustrated with the rising prices and underwhelming quality from the usual suspects around Western New York. So when I noticed Favorite’s Pizza had opened up on Sweet Home Road, I figured I’d roll the dice—and I’m glad I did. Favorites absolutely delivered. The pizza? Thin, crispy, and packed with real flavor. None of that synthetic cheese taste you get from bigger chains. You can tell the ingredients are a step above. It hit that perfect balance between crunch and chew, with a sauce-to-cheese ratio that actually makes sense. The wings were solid as well—classic Buffalo flavor with a nice medium kick that didn’t overpower. That said, they weren’t quite as crispy as I had hoped, even after requesting them extra crispy. If wings are your main mission, I’d still give the edge to Audubon North next door, where I’ve been a longtime loyalist. That said, when it comes to overall value and quality, Favorites beats out places like Franco’s or Just Pizza without question. Reasonable prices, excellent pizza, and wings that are close enough to keep me happy. They’ve officially earned a spot in my regular rotation.